The CCH has been contacted by several housing co-ops recently regarding the issue of digital online general and committee meetings where the co-op has not updated its rules to permit such meetings to take place.
The CCH needs to stress that it is not qualified or indemnified to give legal advice and that our official advice is that co-ops need to seek the advice of their solicitors regarding these matters.
However, we can set out the legal advice we have received and our understanding of the issues.
Many housing co-ops are registered under model housing co-op rules registered in 1981 or with rules that predated the advent of the internet. This meant that their rules do not permit digital online meetings.
At the start of the pandemic the Government recognised that some societies and companies had such difficulties, and included in the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act (2020) an ability for such organisations to hold meetings digital online meetings even if their rules did not permit them to do so.
However, this provision only lasted until the end of March 2021. The MHCLG has published a statement on their website to the effect that they intend to renew the provisions of the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act, but the legal advice we have received is that:
- the measures relating to insolvency have been extended until 29th April 2022
- the measures relating to the ability to hold meetings online expired at the end of March 2021 and have not been extended.
The intention was that organisations should have used the earlier facility to hold General Meetings online to change their rules to permit them subsequently to hold digital online meetings.
Throughout most of 2020 and into 2021, the CCH has been publicising this issue and advising our housing co-op members to either update to new model housing co-op rules we have registered or to at least include provisions in their existing rules to hold digital online meetings.
If housing co-ops have not updated their rules to enable digital online meetings, then our understanding is that technically co-ops that do not have an express provision in their rules to hold digital online meetings would not be in compliance with their rules if they hold either their General or Committee meetings online.
What are the consequences of this problem?
A housing co-op that is not strictly in compliance with their rules is open to challenge by any of its members or other stakeholders. How likely members or others would be to mount such a challenge is a matter for each co-op to judge. And how such a legal challenge would be received in the courts is difficult to know.
However, the issues become potentially more serious for Registered Provider housing co-ops, in that the regulatory framework requires that Registered Providers comply fully with their rules. Registered Provider landlords are required to state categorically in their annual accounts that they are fully in compliance with the Governance and Viability Regulatory Standard – of which compliance with the organisation’s rules is a part. If a co-op knowingly states that they are in compliance with the Governance and Viability Standard in their accounts but is not in compliance with their rules then they are technically in breach of the regulatory standard.
What can housing co-ops in this position do?
At the outset of the pandemic and before the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act (2020) was passed, the CCH’s solicitors advised that co-ops who did not have provision for digital meetings in their rules add a clause at the start of their minutes stating that the meeting had been held digitally as a result of the pandemic. At that time, it was considered that this could be sufficient because co-ops at that time had no alternative but to hold meetings in such a way.
The CCH would urge co-ops who do not now have provisions for digital online meetings in their rules to seek legal advice from their solicitors as to whether including such a statement in their minutes might be sufficient now.
However, the only real and lasting way to resolve the problem is that housing co-ops that do not have provision in their rules for digital online meetings is that they amend their rules to include such a provision.
The CCH has published guidance (available here) that sets out how this can be done. The CCH registered model rules in 2017 specifically aimed at Registered Provider housing co-ops that not only included the use of digital meetings but also updated the rules generally – not least referring to the Co‑operative and Community Benefit Societies Act (2014) under which all co‑operative societies are now registered.
However, to update co-op rules requires a vote to change them at a quorate General Meeting carried by a majority set out in a co-op’s existing rules regarding rule changes. If a co-op does not have the provision to hold a General Meeting digitally in their current rules, then a General Meeting held digitally to change the rules could always be subject to challenge.
This therefore means that a housing co-op wanting to change its rules that does not have provision to hold meetings digitally needs to hold a General Meeting to change the rules on a face to face basis if it wants to be confident that it will not be subsequently open to challenge. Again, the CCH advises that co-ops in this situation seek advice from their solicitors regarding the best course of action.